A 3D Future is Missing a Dimension

Donate Now

Issue 306
January/February 2018
The Way of the Garden

Reviews

A 3D Future is Missing a Dimension
by

issue cover 306

Cover: Bloom Day Scan © Craig Cramer, http://ellishollow.remarc.com

Issue availability

Back issue available

Issue available as PDF

Reprint permissions

A provoking new study of globalisation identifies the problem but offers the wrong solutions, argues Helena Norberg-Hodge. From Global to Local: the Making of Things and the End of Globalization by Finbarr Livesey. Profile Books, 2017. ISBN: 9781781256596

You should never judge a book by its cover. Nor, I now know, by its title. From Global to Local: The Making of Things and the End of Globalization seemed to say it all. Here at last was a significant figure – an academic from Cambridge University, no less – talking the language of economic localisation. I thumbed through the table of contents with real anticipation, even excitement. Perhaps I had found a new soulmate: someone who not only understood the perils inherent in globalisation, but also had come to the conclusion that we needed to head in precisely the opposite direction.

But what a disappointment! Chapter by troubling chapter, it emerges that Finbarr Livesey’s take on localisation leaves the key assumptions and frameworks that underpin neoliberal economics unchallenged, and thereby keeps the fundamentals of corporate rule firmly in place.

Front and centre in Livesey’s thinking are two interrelated assumptions: that progress requires economic growth, and that economic growth requires industrial production and high technology. He is not alone in this analysis; in fact, these two assumptions encapsulate the worldview of mainstream economists, politicians and commentators. But I would argue passionately that they are simply wrong. If we allow our minds to be enclosed in a reductionist, econometric way of seeing the world, we are denying our own nature; we are denying biological realities – life itself.

While I reject many, if not most, of Livesey’s conclusions, I cannot fault much of his argument for the end of globalisation, nor his clarion call about the perils of unbridled competition. He recognises, too, that Nature has its limits, and he is unequivocal in the threat posed by climate change. He provides strong arguments for the need to move away from planned obsolescence, and makes a clear case for the “circular economy”.

But there is no vision of a better world. Though he warns against techno-utopianism, the only future he presents – albeit without much enthusiasm – is a sterile, soulless one of robots and 3D printing: prosperity achieved by distancing ourselves ever more from the natural world. In other words, going local digitally. There is very little questioning of what digitalisation will mean for our jobs, for our communities, for our sense of who we are. By contrast, we are invited to marvel at the extraordinary growth of global industrial output, resulting in the 10 billion unique products now available to us as consumers.

My own starting point could hardly be more different. As I see it, creating viable economic systems cannot happen without bringing the economy down to Earth – to the interdependent biosphere that is the source of every last thing we manufacture and use. Crucially, that means recognising the central importance of food and agriculture. This is quite literally the bread and butter of a resilient economy, and yet unsurprisingly – and in keeping with the bias of most of the policymakers and CEOs who are shaping our future – it merits barely a mention in Livesey’s book.

The kinds of truly localised economy that are required to prevent further cultural destruction and ecocide are nowhere to be seen in this book, but they are emerging in the writings of alternative thinkers and in civil-society movements. Out of the machine-made reality that comprises modern urban existence, there is a deep longing welling up: an unstoppable force towards life – towards the plants, animals, stones, earth and water that we co-evolved with. Worldwide, in a global local food movement, people are reconnecting with the sources of their food: growing their own or getting to know nearby farmers and small producers.

Ever more people are rejecting a passive consumer culture in favour of local, face-to-face participation – with music, song, dance and theatre. Rather than enriching distant investors and anonymous corporations, they are enriching their own lives by rebuilding community.

Livesey is right: globalisation is coming to an end. Let’s hope that we can liberate ourselves from the worldview that lay behind it and forge a more sane, humane and liveable future.

Helena Norberg-Hodge is the Director of Local Futures.

Share this page

The Resurgence Trust is an educational charity that publishes Resurgence & Ecologist magazine, Resurgence.org and theEcologist.org to promote ecological sustainability, social justice and spiritual values. Read our vision statement

© The Resurgence Trust | Terms & Conditions | Privacy | Registration & Login Help | Sitemap | Contact Us

The Resurgence Trust publishes Resurgence & Ecologist magazine. Registered Charity Number: 1120414